The Original Papa Nick's
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM |
| Thursday | 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM |
| Friday | 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM |
| Saturday | 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
The Original Papa Nick's Reviews (108)
Sold pizza for the price point. The garlic knots are really good and COVERED in minced garlic.
My friends and I are spending a few days in Mars Hill and stumbled across The Original Papa Nick's and decided to give it a try, and I am so glad we did. We went on a Friday night and the indoor dining was considerably busy, but we only had to wait about 5-10 minutes before being seated. The inside of Papa Nick's is such a cute, cozy place and our server Becky was amazing. The food was delicious! We ordered their specials of stuffed salmon and chicken and cheese manicotti, and we devoured everything. The peanut butter now was delicious as well. I will definitely be recommending The Original Papa Nick's to anyone that I know is visiting the area!
Food and service was excellent. It gets very loud and acoustics aren't that good. So difficult to carry on a conversation. That could be a big plus depending on who you are with. But we are repeat customers. Lasagna is terrific along with the VERY garlic knots. Yum. Great place.
Our trip to Mars Hill wasn't supposed to involve a stop here, but sometimes things don't work out how you planned. We were in town on a Wednesday and little did we know the place we wanted to go was closed. We considered another location, but it didn't have alcohol so as luck would have it we ended up at Papa Nick's. We are able to wet our whistle with a drink and fill out bellies at the same time. I had the chicken manicotti, salad and delicious bread. The bread was so rich in garlic, it will keep the vampires away but I loved it. The manicotti was very good as well. My friend had the lasagna and was equally as pleased and stuffed. It was a good size piece and for some might even result in leftovers. This place has a long history of being in the business for yummy food - stop over and check them out if you are in the area.
If you’re in Mars Hill, North Carolina, and craving a delicious meal with a homey touch, The Original Papa Nick's is the place you need to visit. Nestled at 15 College St Mars Hill, NC 28754, this local gem offers a mix of hearty comfort food that’ll make you feel right at home. Whether you're in the mood for a fresh salad, a delicious pizza, or just a cold drink to quench your thirst, The Original Papa Nick's has something to satisfy every craving.
Enjoy Fresh and Flavorful Salads at The Original Papa Nick's
At The Original Papa Nick's, the salads are more than just a side dish—they’re a key part of the experience. A standout option is the Greek Salad, packed with fresh ingredients like crisp lettuce, cucumbers, olives, and tangy feta cheese, all tossed together in a zesty dressing. It’s a perfect choice for anyone craving something light yet satisfying, and it's ideal for those looking for a healthier option alongside their pizza or as a standalone meal.
Savory Pizzas that Define The Original Papa Nick's
No visit to The Original Papa Nick's would be complete without sampling their expertly crafted pizzas. The menu features several small 10-inch pizza options that cater to all kinds of taste buds. Whether you’re a fan of traditional flavors or something a little more unique, you’ll find a pizza that hits the spot.
The Cheese Pizza | Small 10" is a classic favorite, featuring a perfect blend of mozzarella and marinara sauce that’s sure to make any pizza lover smile. For those who enjoy a heartier option, the Meat Deluxe Pizza | Small 10" packs a punch with a combination of savory meats that satisfy even the most ravenous appetites.
If you’re a fan of a rich, creamy base, the White Pizza | Small 10" is a must-try, topped with a smooth white sauce and a mix of cheese that delivers a melt-in-your-mouth experience. Alternatively, Pepperoni & Ricotta Pizza | Small 10" offers a delightful twist on a classic with the addition of creamy ricotta cheese alongside the familiar zest of pepperoni.
And for those who love a tangy, smoky flavor, the BBQ Chicken Pizza is a standout, with tender chicken pieces smothered in BBQ sauce that complements the pizza perfectly. Each pizza is made with fresh, high-quality ingredients, ensuring that every bite is bursting with flavor.
Refreshing Drinks to Complete Your Meal at The Original Papa Nick's
No meal is complete without the perfect drink, and The Original Papa Nick's offers a selection that pairs beautifully with their menu. For a classic choice, enjoy a Soft Drink or Bottled Water to keep things refreshing. But if you’re in the mood for something a little different, the Guayaki Yerbe Mate provides a unique energy boost with its earthy flavor, perfect for those who want something energizing and refreshing to enjoy with their meal.
The Unique Charm of The Original Papa Nick's
What sets The Original Papa Nick's apart from other restaurants in Mars Hill is its unique atmosphere. This cozy, family-friendly spot exudes charm and warmth, making it the perfect place to relax and enjoy a meal with loved ones or friends. The service is friendly, and the staff go out of their way to make sure you feel like part of the family. Whether you're sitting down to enjoy a casual lunch or celebrating a special occasion, the welcoming environment at The Original Papa Nick's makes every visit feel special.
I ,ove this restaurant good food , pleasant atmosphere, great servers and prices. Deserts are to die for.