If you ever find yourself craving a slice of comfort, The Original Papa Nick’s menu is your happy place. Their Greek Salad, brimming with crisp cucumbers, ripe tomatoes, kalamata olives, and feta, feels like a sunny afternoon in Santorini, while the Side Salad offers a light, fresh start before diving into the real show: the hot, melty masterpieces.
Their Hot Subs deserve a standing ovation, especially the Meatball Hoagie, drenched in marinara and gooey cheese, and the Hot Italian Sub, bursting with savory layers, alongside the comforting Hot Ham & Swiss Sub.
The Calzones are a pocket of happiness, from the classic Ricotta & Mozzarella Cheese Calzone to the loaded Meat Deluxe Calzone and herbaceous Greek Calzone. If you lean toward Strombolis, their Cheese & 2-Topping Stromboli is a crowd-pleaser, while the Veggie Stromboli and Greek Stromboli balance freshness and indulgence with every bite.
And oh, the Pizzas. Whether you’re grabbing a small 10” or going big with a 14”, you’ll find comfort in the simplicity of a Cheese Pizza, or go bold with the Deluxe 5-Topping and Meat Deluxe options, each with a perfect crust that’s crisp yet pillowy. Their Greek Pizza is a bright, tangy twist, while the Veggie Pizza offers a rainbow of flavors without guilt.
Don’t overlook their Baked Dinners like Spaghetti & Meatballs or Jumbo Cheese Ravioli, each bubbling in a sea of marinara, comforting and generous. Pair your meal with Homemade Garlic Rolls and a fizzy Soft Drink for the full experience.
For gluten-free friends, Papa Nick’s has your back with 10” Gluten-Free and Cauliflower Crust Pizzas that don’t sacrifice flavor.
Every dish feels made with care, turning your meal into a moment worth remembering.